Quick Sugarloaf FL MLS Search

Browse All Sugarloaf FL Properties for Sale

$1,920,000
3 Beds 3 Baths 608877 MLS
Welcome to ''The Key Lime House''.... Your waterfront Paradise in Lower Sugarloaf Key, nestled along the tranquil shores of Sugarloaf Sound. This 3 bedroom 3 bath home offers incredible morning views of sunrise, reflections of evening sunsets from across the bay & sparkling clear waters showing off the warm colors of the sky. As you step onto the property, you're greeted by a lush tropical oasis, complete with banana trees, mango trees, Hawaiian pineapples, native and exotic dragon fruit, cherry trees, and sugar apple trees, providing a bounty of fresh fruits right in your own backyard. The home itself features an open floor plan with 2 bedrooms & 2 baths up PLUS a large Master Suite on the first level. Tile & wood flooring throughout, ample storage, large walk-in closet, standing seam metal roof, a full house generator, great outdoor area, cistern capable of holding up to 800 gallons for plant irrigation, paver driveway & paths and lots of parking space for all your toys...plus climate-controlled garage & storage and room for a pool too...Step onto the back porch and marvel at its unique design, inspired by the bow of a boat, offering the perfect spot to take in the breathtaking sunrise views. An outdoor shower in the yard provides a refreshing escape after a day spent enjoying the water. Enjoy evenings on the spacious front porch facing the sunsets or relax on the back porch with its stunning sunrise views. The property features a full seawall with concrete steps leading into the water, as well as a floating swimming platform and dock complete with boat davits. Two storage sheds, two kayaks with a storage stand, and lush mature landscaping. Home & location offers everything you need for waterfront living at its finest in one of the best neighborhoods. Just about 15 minutes from Key West, this is truly a once-in-a-lifetime opportunity to own your slice of paradise in the Florida Keys.

345 South Point Drive, Sugarloaf

$1,499,900
3 Beds 2 Baths 608870 MLS
Iconic Key West Character at this sprawling 1,859 Sq. Ft. Canal Front home in desirable Sugarloaf Shores! Located on the no-bridge side of Sugarloaf Key, with a generous 55' dock with 10K boat lift, enjoy world-class fishing and diving from this ideal location. Upon entry, the Great Room is open and airy with soaring cathedral ceilings, and is flooded with natural light. Striking hardwood floors, wood-burning fireplace, 6'' baseboards, and fluted doorjamb trim add warmth and vibrance to the space. Five sets of pocket sliding glass doors open onto an expansive veranda, oriented to take advantage of sublime Eastern sea breezes, for year round indoor-outdoor living. Entertain for the masses in the spacious kitchen, featuring abundant storage and prep space, wood cabinetry with custom built-ins, and stainless steel appliances. A generous dining room offers space for gathering with family and friends, and boasts serene Canal Views. A spacious bonus room provides potential for personalization, and could easily be utilized as a home office, media room, or additional bedroom. Two large bedrooms provide comfortable accommodation and come complete with generous closet space. An upstairs laundry room offers added convenience and storage. Downstairs, the attached, permitted two-car garage is truly a rare find! Enjoy an abundance of secure parking, as well as open parking and trailer storage in the front yard. An additional, sizable downstairs storage room allows for keeping tools and equipment out of the elements. The large screened-in patio boasts a jetted, heated swim spa for relaxing with evening cocktails. The backyard offers well-maintained green space and mature trees; this property feels abundantly quiet and private! This home was made for enjoying the outdoors; your ideal Florida Keys lifestyle awaits at this exceptional home in sought-after Sugarloaf Key! Call to schedule a showing today.

146 Sugarloaf Drive, Sugarloaf

$1,650,000
2 Beds 2 Baths 608381 MLS
Escape to this special property thru a luxurious tropical garden filled with orchids, established fruit trees and other exotic plants providing privacy and peace. The gardens have been recently irrigated to provide easier care. Not only is it a gardener's paradise but pleasure abounds for the boater and avid fisherman. Located on a deep canal on the desirable Sugarloaf Key, it is minutes from the back country and Atlantic Ocean. Set back from the road, this huge lot (100 x 200) offers privacy opening onto a lovely 2 bedroom newly remodeled home. There is plenty of parking - under cover and in the open for trailers or an RV. Walk up the new staircase and relax on the open deck or enjoy the large screened in porch for open air dining or gathering. With views over the tropical gardens or canal you realize you are in paradise. Below and overlooking the canal, is a lovely spacious and shaded composite deck with plenty of seating looking out at the canal, bay and mangroves across the canal. There is no home directly across adding to the property's privacy. Slide your kayaks or other toys into the canal from your own boat ramp. Inside, enjoy the open layout with newly remodeled kitchen including quartz countertops and stainless appliances. New laminate flooring with easy care is throughout the house. The ensuite primary bedroom has a lovely quartz walk-in shower and closet. The 2nd bathroom has lovely quartz throughout also. So, whether you are a tropical gardener, boater, or both, this house offers you everything you need to enjoy living in the fabulous Florida Keys.

17365 Keystone Road, Sugarloaf

$1,199,900
2 Beds 2 Baths 608087 MLS
Fantastic Sugarloaf Shores retreat, on an oversized lot with direct access to enviable fishing and diving within minutes! Ideal for the avid boater, this well-maintained property boasts 100' full length concrete dock on an 70'+ wide clean flow-through canal. Enjoy immaculate swimming, kayaking, and paddleboarding from this prime location. Inside, the open-concept main living space is flooded with natural light. High ceilings, custom trim-work, and mirrored transoms add warmth and character to the space, while large windows are oriented to take advantage of prevailing sea breezes. The kitchen offers ample storage and prep space, making entertaining a breeze. Dine al fresco with guests on the expansive screened-in lanai, while enjoying pristine canal views, partial Open Water views, and breathtaking Sunsets! Retire to a well-appointed primary suite, complete with custom built-in storage with reading nook, walk-in closet, and en suite bathroom. Visitors will enjoy comfortable accommodation in a generous guest bedroom with access to a large guest bathroom. Additional features include wrap-around porch, standing seam metal roof, high-efficiency air handler, new washer/dryer and range, and the concrete dock and walkways were re-sealed January 2024. Downstairs, a bonus storage space offers room for keeping tools and fishing gear dry and secure, and the spacious covered carport provides shaded parking and entertaining space. Boasting over a quarter acre, with plenty of room to add a pool, this well-maintained lot features lighting and irrigation, and is adorned with lush tropical landscaping, making the property feel abundantly serene and private. Situated within the confines of an established, quiet neighborhood but just a short drive to delectable restaurants and convenience stores in town, this location has it all! Don't miss the opportunity to own this exceptional slice of paradise. Call to schedule a tour today!

17055 W Kingfish Lane, Sugarloaf

$1,249,000
3 Beds 2 Baths 607904 MLS
Discover this charming 3-bedroom, 2-bathroom canal-front home nestled in the sought-after community of Sugarloaf Shores. This residence has undergone recent renovations, beginning with the newly remodeled kitchen, complete with custom granite countertops, a stylish backsplash, and stainless steel appliances. The entire home boasts designer Hunter ceiling fans and elegant tile flooring and both the master bedroom and master bathroom feature Italian marble floors. The master bath features a new ''soaker tub'' surrounded by marble tiling. A dual vanity with hammered copper sinks and oil rubbed bronze matching faucets complete the stunning look. This home also features newly installed window casements and storm impact windows (no hurricane shutters needed!).Step outside through the rear French doors to an expansive composite sun deck, recently installed in 2021. This space provides an inviting setting for outdoor living and dining, perfect for entertaining friends and family. With multiple levels, you have options for creating the perfect outdoor oasis to suit your lifestyle.One of the standout features of this property is the Tiki hut-covered swim spa and hot tub. Relax and rejuvenate in this private setting while taking in the serene views. Privacy is further enhanced by the presence of a large mangrove island in the natural canal, creating a tranquil backdrop.A private boat ramp and 40-foot dock overlook the Mangrove Island adding maximum waterfront privacy for this property. With quick boating access to Atlantic and Gulf of Mexico, this property is ideal for both fishermen and boaters.A tropical oasis of foliage (including fruit bearing banana trees) surrounds this gorgeous home in one of the highest resale neighborhoods in the Lower Keys. The spacious carport under house includes a TESLA charging system. A RING security system with outdoor lighting has been installed throughout the property. This home sells furnished with a tasteful tropical decor.

17240 Oleander Lane, Sugarloaf

$2,200,000
2 Beds 2 Baths 607787 MLS
Stunning Open Water views from this fantastic waterfront home on a 20,583 Sq. Ft. lot in sought-after Sugarloaf Shores! This expansive, well-maintained lot is Southwest-facing, providing breathtaking Sunset Views from the exceptional Great Room, wherein impact-resistant pocket sliding glass doors open to unobstructed Water Views. The well-equipped kitchen boasts ample storage space and features a peninsula with bar seating; an ideal space for entertaining guests while cooking up the day's catch. Two sizable bedrooms, both with en-suite bathrooms and walk-in closets, provide comfortable accommodation for visitors and family. The spacious screened-in patio just off the main living area lends itself to entertaining, enjoy outdoor dining while taking in stunning Open Ocean Views and Keys Famous Sunsets. The spacious backyard comes equipped with a concrete dock and davits located on a crystal-clear canal and affords additional space for adding a pool. Davits are currently accommodating a 2022 Scout 195 Sport Dorado available for purchase separately. The spectacular home has been meticulously maintained and boasts sturdy concrete construction, sitting high and dry on the property with no flooding from any storms. Nestled within a quiet neighborhood but just minutes from shops and restaurants, Sugarloaf Shores is an upscale waterfront community boasting pristine canals and biking and hiking trails, all just 20 minutes from the magic of Key West! Call to schedule a tour today!

17026 W Bonita Lane, Sugarloaf

$1,820,000
3 Beds 3 Baths 607145 MLS
Introducing an exceptional opportunity to acquire a vast property in the heart of Sugarloaf Key. This expansive estate covers over 26,000 square feet, with 1,760 sq. ft of air-conditioned space and room to build.The property features a delightful two bedroom one and a half bathroom main house complimented by a quaint one bedroom, one bath guest house, ideal for accommodating visitors. !! Large lanai overlooks the pool with built in spa, swim jet and waterfall. New pool equipment was installed in '22 with high efficiency pumps and heater.The extensive site is currently partitioned into three lots, offering ample space to construct your dream luxury home and park your RV. Located just down the street is a private boat launch, offering some of the finest water access in the Florida Keys, For any family, within walking distance of the property is the the highly-regarded Sugarloaf School. For those working remotely, the property includes two spacious offices, which could potentially be repurposed as bedrooms. These offices offer a tranquil and comfortable environment for productivity and creativity.The outdoor amenities are equally impressive, featuring a large outdoor bar and kitchen with adjacent separate fish cleaning sinks.It boasts 9 seating and dining areas throughout the property and has an outdoor ping pong table, Pool table, horseshoe and a beach volleyball court.In addition, there is a greenhouse with well irrigation for ease of plant and garden care.There are 6 off street parking spaces for vehicles and boats in front of house with 10 foot gates to access for more private storage or parking. This property also features an added unique opportunity to build a custom home on 10,000 square feet of land in one of the most sought-after areas of Sugarloaf Key. These lots already have 6 ft fencing with landscaping and a 16 foot custom gate for access from Seminole St. Don't miss this rare chance to create your dream home

19512 Aztec Street, Sugarloaf

$2,399,000
3 Beds 3 Baths 607012 MLS
Stunning Sugarloaf Retreat with private sandy beach, sparkling pool, and sprawling dockage! This turnkey, coastal home offers elevated seaside living, with designer finishes and a resort feel. Entertain like never before in the bright and spacious main living area, with soaring cathedral ceilings and jaw-dropping Views of the Gulf of Mexico. Cook for the masses in the expertly equipped Chef's kitchen, boasting high end stainless steel appliances, including gas range with vent hood and industrial size refrigerator, quartz countertops and backsplash, kitchen island with seating, abundant storage, and sizeable pantry. Dine al fresco and take in the endless sea breezes from the screened-in back patio, or enjoy peaceful Open Water Views from the adjoining open back porch. Visitors will enjoy comfortable accommodations in either of two generous guest bedrooms, while the primary suite features a luxurious en suite bathroom, large walk-in closet, and private balcony with panoramic views of the Gulf and manicured yard below. Host endless summer gatherings in a back yard oasis, complete with in-ground pool, private beach, and lush tropical landscaping offering loads of privacy. Just steps from the sand, an oversized dock allows for frequent boating adventures with ease. Store kayaks, paddleboards, boating equipment, and multiple vehicles out of the elements in a massive 4-car garage, easily accessed from garage doors on both the front and back of the home. A brick paver driveway provides additional open parking. Nestled within the established Indian Mound Estates neighborhood but just minutes to nearby shops, restaurants, and schools, this exceptional property won't last long. Schedule a tour today!

19527 Indian Mound Drive, Sugarloaf

$5,750,000
6 Beds 4 Baths 606856 MLS
LUXURY WITH BREATHTAKING SUNSETS AND SUNRISES! Welcome to Sugarloaf Villa! A Stunning Waterfront property which sits on over 1 acre of land and is designed with impeccable taste and luxury. Upon entering this spectacular home you are greeted by an Italian handcrafted floor tile inspired by our wonderful Keys marine life. Next you will enter the grand yet inviting living space with expansive windows that effortlessly incorporate the outdoors view. Open Bay Views and Breathtaking Sunrises which you will never tire of! Open floor plan and Wonderful kitchen with high end stainless appliances and gas stove which will delight the chef in you and make for incredible entertaining possibilities! With 6 bedrooms and 4 baths this spacious home has plenty of room for all! The Gated Villa is nestled in a green landscape surrounded by mangrove and lush palm trees. A paradise for Ocean lovers and fishermen, the Sugarloaf Bay is easy access to both the Gulf and the Atlantic side. Also minutes away from Marvin Key. where you may spend the most memorable time enjoying the quiet sand bars with the most pristine clear water. Just in front of the Villa you may try lobstering during the season, as well as enjoying paddle boarding and kayaking in the calm Bay. Its elegant and contemporary decor, with nautical theme and vibrant key west blue pastel colors, create a peaceful and chic ambience. Other features and amenities of the property, a wonderful Heated pool overlooking 239 feet of Open Bay water frontage! Shuffle board, fire pit, and lots of room for all of the fun activities. A basin and a spacious long dock accommodating boats requiring up to 3 ft draft and other water toys. Three different outdoor dining areas 2 terraces and 3 balconies to enjoy the natural surroundings. Allini Condo Hybrid water filter for kitchen and refrigerator. Nest AC control and fire control. Fresh Water Pond with fish and fountain. A marvelous long table for family dinners under the stars in Paradise!

681 Sugarloaf Boulevard, Sugarloaf

$1,995,000
3 Beds 3 Baths 606444 MLS
One-Of-A-Kind Luxury Waterfront Concrete Home! on prestigious Sugarloaf Key, just 20 mins from Key West. This home is unique, being well elevated above neighbors to captivate the allure of stunning open water views. 8 ft. sliding impact glass doors open onto a spacious covered porch for ultimate entertaining. This home's unique elevated design not only amplifies the views but also offers a practical solution during inclement weather, thanks to the roof over a protected stairwell that provides access from the parking area below. 1000 LB capacity Cargo Lift equipped with remote operation. Easily transport luggage, groceries, and more effortlessly between floors. The front door and interior foyer welcome visitors with accented walls adorned in tumbled marble, setting a tone of elegance and sophistication. The primary suite has exceptional open water views. Enjoy the freedom of sunbathing on open private decks with privacy in mind. The gourmet kitchen and spacious living area seamlessly integrate with the outdoors. Start your day with stunning views in the cozy breakfast nook. 10 ft ceilings throughout. There are 2 covered porches with a total of 655 sq ft plus 1,184 sq ft of open decking. All Low E hurricane impact glass. There are 2 Guest Suites each with designer baths and huge walk in closets. A Formal Dining Room. An additional room which could be used as an office, 4th bedroom or family room. Large Laundry Room. 2,856 sq ft under the house with ceiling height over 14.5 ft allows for parking of cars and very tall boats and trailers. Two bays have been planned to accommodate 2 of the largest RV's. House is over engineered with oversized rebar and 4000 PSI concrete. 24-guage galvalume standing seam steel roof, lifetime decking, tongue and groove ceilings on porches. Whole house generator runs on 3 propane tanks. 15,000 LB Boat Lift. Large 12,500 SF lot with plenty of room to build your dream pool and spa. Low insurances Flood $500 Wind $3000 Home $1400 Total $4900

17057 W Bonita Lane, Sugarloaf

$7,995,000
6 Beds 6 Baths 605640 MLS
Introducing Blue Water Lagoon, a stunning 2.33-acre property that embodies coastal luxury and offers an exceptional waterfront lifestyle. The grand Chicago brick paved driveway guides you to this remarkable property, surrounded by meticulously landscaped grounds. Indulge in the exclusive private marina, featuring dockage and outstanding amenities like a 25,000 lb boat lift, a 16,000 lb boat lift, and two extra boat slips. Boating enthusiasts will appreciate the additional allure of a boat ramp, old boat house area, and sea wall boat space. Enjoy the picturesque view of the iconic American Shoal lighthouse and revel in the serenity of your own private beach. Entertain guests from your oversized outdoor cabana bar and relax in the zero-entry pool. A recently rebuilt wood observation deck provides a perfect spot to soak in the coastal splendor. Step onto the screened-in downstairs porch and indulge in the coastal ambiance. A spiral staircase leads you to the upstairs entry, where bamboo floors and mesmerizing views grace the beautifully designed living spaces. The open kitchen boasts custom cabinetry and top-of-the-line Viking appliances. This residence was the site of the feature film ''True Lies,'' adding a touch of Hollywood glamour to the property. Blue Water Lagoon offers a total of six bedrooms with three located downstairs. Two of these bedrooms share a convenient Jack and Jill bathroom, while the third bedroom features an en-suite bathroom. Additionally, a maid's quarters equipped with an ice maker, deep freezer, and laundry facilities add an extra layer of convenience. Upstairs you'll find three more bedrooms. The primary suite offers an en-suite bathroom and the other two bedrooms with a Jack and Jill bathroom plus a half bathroom. The luxurious primary suite features a glam room and a private bathroom with a shower and soaking tub. It boasts a one car garage, lockers for convenience and a whole-house generator. See Supplement.

16750 Old State Road 4a, Sugarloaf

$749,000
605046 MLS
This gorgeous canal front lot with active building permit is located on Keystone Road, one of Sugarloaf Shores premier streets where all properties are set on 20,000 + sq. ft. waterfront lots on the no bridge side of Sugarloaf Key. Being one of the last buildable lots in the Lower Keys this house will be built to the new building codes which are the most hurricane resistant in the state of Florida allowing for low insurance costs. Build your dream home YOUR way with the best hurricane construction (unlike many older homes requiring higher insurance costs) and build it right once to save costs over time. Extensive mature landscaping and 1.4 mile distance from noisy US1 ensures privacy and serenity, with extra room for large pool, tiki, gardens, boat and trailer storage, etc.. Army Corp approvals are in place for a 70' seawall with 15K lb boat lift offering quick and easy ocean access through Tarpon Creek. Lots of mature landscaping creates a private and serene backdrop for your new home. Seller's plans are included in the sale which can be changed to suit your own home design. Sugarloaf Key enjoys beautiful bike paths, hiking trails, full service marina with boat ramp and an upscale waterfront restaurant. Lots of world-class waterfront adventures await just minutes away including deep sea and back country fishing, paddling and kayaking though Sugarloaf's mangrove creeks, picnicking at the beaches at Marvin and Snipe Key, and diving and snorkeling in crystal clear waters and the coral reefs at Looe Key. Just 15 minutes to the magic of Key West.

17295 Keystone Road, Sugarloaf

$1,450,000
3 Beds 3 Baths 604898 MLS
Stunning Canal Front living with enviable boating in desirable Sugarloaf Shores! This home has it all, sprawling square footage with tasteful upgrades on a sizeable lot with proximity to great boating. A bright, open-concept main living space greets you upon entry. European influence adds warmth and vibrance to space, while modern finishes provide an elevated, comfortable island lifestyle. The chef's kitchen comes equipped for all culinary prowess, featuring a spacious island with counter seating, stylish bronze sink and vent hood, modern white cabinetry, pot filler, ample prep- and storage space, and top-of-the-line Miele Appliances. The spacious split floor plan affords exceptional accommodation between two generous guest bedrooms and a well-appointed primary suite, with rare walk-in closet. For the ultimate luxury experience, the en suite bathroom retreat comes complete with clawfoot tub and oversized glass steam shower and boasts private access the balcony. Additionally, a substantial back balcony provides the perfect backdrop for enjoying the warm summer breeze while sipping cocktails at sunset. Downstairs, a covered outdoor living space comes equipped for entertaining with a striking blood cypress bar serving as the focal point of the space. Approximately 80 feet of concrete dock with davits and kayak launch makes for easy access to infamous fishing and diving within minutes, and two bubblers allow for carefree maintenance of your pristine canal! Indulge in a variety of local fruit trees such as coconut, guava, banana, key lime, and many more. Enjoy ample paved parking and storage on this 10,050 sq ft lot, while lush native landscaping provides privacy and seclusion from the outside world. Your own slice of paradise is in store at this Sugarloaf Shores sanctuary. Schedule a showing today!

16941 Driftwood Lane, Sugarloaf

Start Your Search

Sugarloaf Real Estate

Our website features the best real estate search for homes, condos, land and foreclosure properties available in Sugarloaf and surrounding areas. It is the only site you will ever need! It is easy-to-use and updated by the official Realtor®’s database every 15 minutes. 

You can save searches, and get daily email alerts of new listings, price changes, sold data, and market reports. Our Interactive Map Search allows you to view properties on a map or refine your search by drawing the boundaries around the area you desire. 

Curious about what’s happening in your neighborhood? You can create a custom market report to see what’s active, under contract, and sold in your neighborhood! 

Considering selling or refinancing your home? Get an INSTANT property valuation now!

Contact us today to find out how we can be of assistance to you!